How much does a street cost? (Infographic)

Add to Facebook download .zip with all pictures

I can speak to your points with a fair amount of knowledge actually, as I have worked in the Traffic Ops section of my state’s DOT and even the electrical research division, with light controllers and census detectors.

>whatever underground piping is in use can surely be replaced by sealed pvc

Not really; PVC has less than 140 PSI maximum operating pressure in a 12″ main, is prone to cracking during earthquakes, is highly flammable (PVC is literally used for amateur rocket fuel when coupled with an oxidizer), is prone to cracking under freezing temperatures, is UV sensitive (cannot be stored outside for long periods of time, unlike metal/concrete pipe), and can contaminate drinking water and other materials it carries with VOCs (volatile organic compounds). Engineers don’t sit around bored and try to come up with the most ridiculous, bullshit solution to a problem just for shits and giggles. Construction standards are set in place by local, regional, state, and federal mandates and they weren’t just thought up while buzzed off a few beers snuck in at lunch.

>There is no reason for a controller box to contain sophisticated equipment like they do.

I’d love for you to explain to me what is “sophisticated” about a traffic controller. The McCain controller used by Caltrans as a standard controller throughout the state uses a Motorola 6800 processor as a controller; no, I didn’t mean a 68000, I mean a 6800. That’s a chip that started production in 1974. The box requires such a strong level of C programming that only a few people in the state *really* know what’s going on inside of it. But we still use them because they’re workhorses, and vetted, and dependable. I’ll get to these points later.

>The reason they do is because the people who design them seem to go with the piss-poor electrical engineering paradigm of “put together generic devices until you have something that works”.

Please provide your evidence for knowing how this worked. I guarantee you pulled it out of your ass because that’s an absolute load of horseshit. In CA we have a state standard, signed off by a Professional Engineer, that is used as a standard plan for every electrical installation in the state. If the plan was half-assed and not well thought out, that P.E.’s license would be on the line, the state’s controllers would be unreliable and in shambles, and we’d have insurmountable traffic problems every day on state routes because of electrical failures. We don’t, and that very fact is testament to fully deny your assumption that these boxes are just thrown together with no forethought.

> You could slash the cost of the box in a tenth by hiring one guy with a little expertise in digital electronics

So you’re willing to put your entire state’s traffic control on the line of some guy with “a little experience”? Enjoy being the singled out person in charge of dealing with all the tort lawsuits because some signal had a bug, caused a fatal car accident, and you’re facing involuntary manslaughter charges. You wouldn’t be facing those charges if you had, say, a licensed and experienced P.E. come up with a standard plan for the whole state, so if anything did happen the State would be responsible, not you or your idea of an independent contractor.

> The board must have a service port to configure it and software can be written for quick intuitive configuration.

Oh, so now you want to broaden the scope of your guy with a little experience to now come up with a controller that has a custom interface for “quick and intuitive” operation? That will require an OS to be designed, a development workstation to be designed, unit and integration testing, and then deployment, plus someone who is either willing to travel throughout the State to deal with maintenance and failures, or training enough people to allow each area of the State to have someone on call, for when the inevitable happens. Have you ever seen a traffic light blinking red? That means the controller crashed and it needs to be reset. Every time that happens throughout the State, you’re going to need to have a technician come out and fix it, someone with enough experience to know the system and get it working, on call 24/7/365. This plan for you to cheapen things up seems to be getting a little more expensive…but let’s go on.

>The relay network would have to be designed per-light but this task could be done by a computer as well.

So now you want to custom design each controller for EVERY CONTROLLER in the State? And somehow, a magical computer is going to do this for you? So now you have to unit and integration test every controller for every possible contingency before it’s vetted enough to be put to use in the State, and when it fails you can prove that it wasn’t just some random bug your guy with “a little experience” didn’t see, or some bug your magical designer computer had? And you want to put the safety of the public, and your tort lawyers on guard against that? I’m thinking your job and experience doesn’t involve a product that goes to public market that if it malfunctioned, could bring tort cases if you’re lucky and manslaughter cases if you weren’t so lucky. And don’t think I’m being extreme; every quarter or so Caltrans puts out a Tort case newsletter, examining the various lawsuits filed against the State for negligent construction site safety or road design, etc. It’s a continuous process.

> You could probably pay one engineer per state in the U.S. to do that job about 40k yearly

You clearly do not understand engineer salaries. Electrical engineers *start* at $60K+, more based on where you live. Absolutely NO ONE is going to put themselves at risk for designing traffic controllers for $40-fucking-thousand a year, you are nuts.

>The PSU for such a unit would be no larger than your typical brick since the lights could run directly on mains power

Sure, if it was in a shirt sleeve environment without freeze/thaw cycles and extreme heat and cold. Traffic controllers have to endure the freezing temps of Sierra Nevada passes, and the baking Death Valley; many of them will be that cold in the winter, and that warm in the summer. That’s beyond industrial level hardiness, that’s military grade weather temps right there.

> Lamp cables could be connected to relays with PowerCon connectors.

Great, so now any dipshit that wants to steal the copper since it’s apparently not in a conduit can shock himself, and if he doesn’t die, sue the State for not protecting him from AC mains. Or some dumb fucking kids who didn’t know better. Plus, powerCON connectors are NOT designed for connections that are meant to stand up to aforementioned temp and weather conditions. The minimum connector that could withstand such punishment would probably be a MIL_DTL-38999 or -26482, but here in the real world we make those connection in conduit so that the public is protected and our cables are protected.

>Take a look at this picture and tell me there isn’t sophisticated equipment here that could easily be replaced by something with the power of a handheld calculator.

Dude, *you don’t even know what you’re looking at!* Sophisticated?! There’s a basic user control panel at the top, below that is a controller with an 8 line LCD display with a hex keypad, a secondary controller box, then a big connection panel, the light controllers, and then an AC mains circuit breaker and a line conditioner. THAT’S IT!!! How the fuck is an 8 line LCD display and “knobs” fucking sophisticated?! If you opened up the box and saw a bunch of blade servers and a NAS that’s one thing, fucking a, man, you really don’t know just so unbelievably simple this box really is. How is that connection panel so ridiculous to you? Do you even know how many connections there can be for one intersection? At a four lane stop with controlled left turns, I just counted at a well known intersection that I happen to know is a State route and there are nearly **70** inputs and outputs; how else would you manually hook all those up? That includes street lamps, lighted signs, census loops for traffic detection, signals, crosswalk buttons, and crosswalk indicators. Many intersections use cameras for traffic detection, how do you think those systems work? That’s an honest to God computer running, with a “sophisticated screen” so that technicians can work on it.

What I can tell you is this: engineers aren’t here to think up the most ridiculous way to solve a problem. We work hard to make things work, and the vast majority of us take personal pride in that. If there was a cheaper, better way to do things, don’t you think we’d be just as interested as you? What crazy world do you think practicing engineers live in where we have no interest in clever, useful solutions that are simple to implement and are as maintenance free as possible? Don’t you think engineers who work for the State are also tax payers and don’t like seeing their money wasted? Don’t you think we’d jump on any chance to make things better? How can you elevate yourself so high above an entire workforce, nay, an entire industry?

Latest Comments
  1. RobbynDosch December 29, 2016
  2. Ustche December 28, 2016
  3. NelsonBakken December 24, 2016
  4. wasdenmzd December 22, 2016
  5. VinitaRezendes December 20, 2016
  6. southwickship5 December 20, 2016
  7. Nulad December 18, 2016
  8. czakNorris1 December 17, 2016
  9. Brivestas December 12, 2016
  10. Cheann December 1, 2016
  11. Iaor November 27, 2016
  12. Iworo November 26, 2016
  13. Schiat November 22, 2016
  14. Zapes November 20, 2016
  15. osade November 20, 2016
  16. GaleBostick November 19, 2016
  17. Yonys November 18, 2016
  18. Endrr November 17, 2016
  19. Tanenth November 14, 2016
  20. Rodyn November 12, 2016
  21. Isquaugh November 9, 2016
  22. Tiaeld November 2, 2016
  23. Nulad November 1, 2016
  24. southwickship5 November 1, 2016
  25. GaleBostick October 30, 2016
  26. Rannund October 29, 2016
  27. CristineLacomb October 27, 2016
  28. Orlye October 27, 2016
  29. sarkisian93 October 25, 2016
  30. Burageorm October 25, 2016
  31. RobbynDosch October 24, 2016
  32. EloyVanostrand October 20, 2016
  33. Odynu October 18, 2016
  34. Jacquiline1999 October 15, 2016
  35. Oasi October 14, 2016
  36. Kinild October 6, 2016
  37. Xojyw October 5, 2016
  38. Cheann October 3, 2016
  39. Dokeg September 27, 2016
  40. Kinild September 19, 2016
  41. Oughumde September 19, 2016
  42. Tiarad September 16, 2016
  43. EunaCalifano September 14, 2016
  44. Iceru September 11, 2016
  45. Rodel September 7, 2016
  46. Tonser September 6, 2016
  47. Queighty September 5, 2016
  48. Emkim August 28, 2016
  49. Iss August 26, 2016
  50. RomaMcray August 16, 2016
  51. Ludser August 16, 2016
  52. Ashend August 15, 2016
  53. lawvercool3 August 11, 2016
  54. Aselme August 10, 2016
  55. Jacquiline1999 August 9, 2016
  56. UrsulaNeel August 1, 2016
  57. kolinmcrae July 31, 2016
  58. vanderpool39 July 29, 2016
  59. Iss July 26, 2016
  60. ThuBocanegra July 16, 2016
  61. LucienneDewees July 12, 2016
  62. Xojyw July 9, 2016
  63. Nitanen July 3, 2016
  64. Lucessinger98 June 25, 2016
  65. hyunsc2 June 24, 2016
  66. Mylil June 23, 2016
  67. PatriciaAcord June 23, 2016
  68. Reavis2000 June 20, 2016
  69. garza77 June 18, 2016
  70. Tiaeld June 16, 2016
  71. Sulghaeng June 11, 2016
  72. guin7865 June 10, 2016
  73. AdalbertoHumes June 7, 2016
  74. tauskny June 6, 2016
  75. milonekilone4 June 5, 2016
  76. ThuBocanegra June 5, 2016
  77. Zapes June 1, 2016
  78. Lucessinger98 May 20, 2016
  79. DavisGroce May 12, 2016
  80. kolinmcrae May 11, 2016
  81. UrsulaNeel May 7, 2016
  82. RomaMcray May 6, 2016
  83. urnisaw May 1, 2016
  84. panzergeneral April 23, 2016
  85. Queighty April 18, 2016
  86. Wartin April 16, 2016
  87. Rel April 15, 2016
  88. barbozaIsland April 13, 2016
  89. Ingn April 12, 2016
  90. Nyest April 12, 2016
  91. tischDE April 8, 2016
  92. UrsulaNeel April 6, 2016
  93. Uskunte April 1, 2016
  94. Isquaugh April 1, 2016
  95. Ceribo March 29, 2016
  96. Tanenth March 26, 2016
  97. Zimmermann169 March 19, 2016
  98. BuenaShore March 17, 2016
  99. NelsonBakken March 12, 2016
  100. Awust March 7, 2016
  101. Isquaugh March 7, 2016
  102. Sylye March 5, 2016
  103. RomaMcray March 1, 2016
  104. Skelashat February 29, 2016
  105. Mcglade666 February 27, 2016
  106. Haizden February 23, 2016
  107. Rac February 22, 2016
  108. Chaiwor February 19, 2016
  109. Mcaaast9 February 18, 2016
  110. Cheann February 10, 2016
  111. tauskny February 9, 2016
  112. Endvesa February 9, 2016
  113. Skelashat February 6, 2016
  114. persaud February 4, 2016
  115. ShellieFiles January 28, 2016
  116. Rodyn January 26, 2016
  117. Rodel January 23, 2016
  118. GastonCoit January 22, 2016
  119. poissonman88 January 18, 2016
  120. RobbynDosch January 9, 2016
  121. Sylye January 4, 2016
  122. Ceribo January 2, 2016
  123. GaleBostick January 1, 2016
  124. Lordnys January 1, 2016
  125. StacyHickox December 23, 2015
  126. brusswszech December 17, 2015
  127. goodellkol December 17, 2015
  128. BuenaShore December 14, 2015
  129. Ceribo December 10, 2015
  130. bellowsE December 6, 2015
  131. Queton December 1, 2015
  132. Skelashat November 22, 2015
  133. Isech November 20, 2015
  134. AlexTibbs November 18, 2015
  135. Nyill November 17, 2015
  136. Laeld November 9, 2015
  137. Tiarad November 8, 2015
  138. Chaiwor November 7, 2015
  139. lamoureux89 November 5, 2015
  140. LeonardEdlund October 29, 2015
  141. Imem October 29, 2015
  142. Tanenth October 27, 2015
  143. Hinoldo October 24, 2015
  144. Inest October 18, 2015
  145. czakNorris1 October 18, 2015
  146. AlexTibbs October 11, 2015
  147. LeolaBou October 9, 2015
  148. LeonardEdlund October 8, 2015
  149. dorothywarkocz5 October 6, 2015
  150. LatashiaReece October 1, 2015
Comments are closed.
Click on Like Page, to get new amazing photo every day on facebook.
Thanks! I already Like.